Eye Pencil (Black - Coal) - Eyeliner with Soothing Chamomile, Meadowfoam & Vitamin E - Smooth & Long Lasting, Hypoallergenic, Non-Irritating Eye Makeup

This eye pencil is really nice. It lasts a long time if you don’t rub your eyes (I do, so I had to reapply). The pigment is really good for a natural looking line. It’s not chalky but goes on really smooth. I wouldn’t purchase this if you’re looking for something bold. Overall, really great!

Great for sensitive eyes. I can wear on the inside of eye lid without irritation! It is long lasting and gluides on smooth. Colors are great . I have black, navy and mocha.

I stopped using eyeliners due to styes, those awful pimple looking bumps. The doctor had said it was because I used old eyeliners, which was not accurate because styes were appearing even with pretty new ones. This eyeliner is the only one that works, and doesn't make the styes form. Great value for what it is, stays put for hours and it looks great.

I love that you can sharpen this and it gives more bang for the buck, but I do have to wet it often because it tends to dry out, and it’ll smudge here or there. Not a bad option and doesn’t irritate my super sensitive skin!

Why did you pick this product vs others?:This is my favorite eyeliner. It doesn't make my eyes water which is really nice. I ordered two of them and will order many more, I'm sure because it seems to be quite natural.

Slides off soon, for me. So I had to reapply it many times a day. Way too much work. :) And concerning because some of the product ended up in my eyes…

I always used department store brands, but this is a good product for less money. A fine line lasts, but it's also soft enough to create a smudged look. The best thing is that my eyes don't itch as much as they did.

I've used it this product for over 10 years and I don't know what they did to the black (coal) formula but now it's horrible. It flakes and gets everywhere but where you want it to go making application really difficult and messy and then finding I look like a mess hours later after I've been interacting with people. I'm so disappointed I had bought several while it was on sale and after getting it all over my hands all over my car all over my keys staining my clothing.. I have to let it go. I'm too late to return because I was out of the country over the holiday season and the fires in LA Which sucks because I had bought a large quantity on sale :( I still use the touch color which I love and don't have these issues so for whatever reason I think it might just be this particular color but I would be warned.