FACESCANADA Faces Canada Longwear Eye Pencil, 5 Bright Color Shades, Smudge Proof, Waterproof, Intense Color, One Stroke Smooth Color, Made In Germany, Peta Approved, Black Sparkle, 0.04 Oz

This is by far the best eyeliner I have ever used! It does not smudge & stays put all day. I will not buy another brand ever!

I like it. It is nice one.

This Faces Canada Longwear Eye Pencil lasts for quite a while on my eyelids, and I like that it's fairly smudge proof and reasonably waterproof. I can remove it fairly easily with my normal micellar water cleanser at the end of the day, so I'm satisfied with it on the whole. I got the "black sparkle" hoping it would have more sparkle than it actually does - but it's barely detectable at all and so subtle that they should have called it a soft black or something else, IMO. Aside from that, it's a decent eyeliner, and I like that it doesn't seem to flake off, even at the end of the day after wearing it for many hours. Depending on what you're looking for, YMMV.

NOT SMUDGE PROOF AND DRIES UP

I really want to love this product, however it is not very smudge proof. The color is fantastic, but it does not wear long at all.

Faces Canada Longwear Eye Pencil,OMG I am in love with this liner - it goes on so easily and stays put. If you want to blend this out, do it immediately after application because it dries quickly. It is so comfortable to wear as well and didn't irritate my eyes. It also stays put and lasts all day.

I bought specifically because it was supposed to be black sparkle; there is absolutely no sparkle. Very disappointed.

This isn't really that sparkly; just enough to make by intense black pencil to have an impact, and it lasts for hours. I like putting it on. So many products out there that I have trouble getting the effect I desire, and I see it disappear within an hour. This one doesn't stretch my eye tissues trying to put it on.I have gone back and forth between deciding to go without, or decide again to use the liner products. Lately I have several I am trying. This one and the marker gel one I tried are equally desireable, yet completely different. Great luck!This is easy to remove with a good solvent/remover. This product seems to me that it is not as oil-based as others are.This lovely item is defintely a great value!Enjoy!