e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented, Long Lasting, Enhances, Defines, Intensifies, Boldens, Grey, All-Day Wear, 0.008 Oz

Firstly, while applying, I had to rub the pencil a lot to be visible on my waterline. Secondly, it smells like crayon, as if the product has gone bad. Such a bad product - Not expected from E.L.F cosmetics.

great product nice colors

creamy and slides on nicely you can smudge it quickly because it dries fast and stays on i really like it

This is a very nice little eyeliner, especially for such a budget-friendly item. It glides on smoothly, and stays put. The taupe color looks natural, not artificial, with my grey/white hair. I’ll buy it again.

They really mean smudge proof when they say it. Which is great for long lasting wear, but… If you make a mistake, you’ll really have to get in there with make up remover.