XtendLash Tubing Mascara - Black - Tubular Lengthening, Volume & Curl - High Definition Lashes - Smudge Proof Water Resistant - Flake Free Glossy Buildable Eye Makeup - Vegan & Cruelty Free

Best tubing mascara I have ever used, and I have tried a lot of them. I have only used tubing mascara for about 5 years now. I hate "racoon eyes" I am prone to tears and I have sensitive skin. This brand is by far my favorite, and very affordable too.

Works well building existing lashes

I really, really wanted to like this mascara. I was so excited to get it. I have been using tubing mascara for years. I have used Thrive and Tarte is my go to. This was half the cost and as the saying goes "you get what you pay for". The mascara was VERY dry upon opening. I used it anyway. At first it went on "okay", with a very quick second coat I was done. It lasted the day. I used it for about a week, by the end of the week it was so dry and went on very, very clumpy I couldn't use it any longer. I tossed it sadly.

This is an excellent product. The first time I used it, my large family came over for a football game. I normally have an issue with water proof mascara because my skin is so oily that it completely negates the effect of the water proofing. In this case, not only did this mascara survive the day drinking that comes with weekend football, but also me wrestling my nieces and nephews for 4 hours straight. My eyelashes feel soft and not in the least bit brittle after wearing this product. Highly recommend if you are concerned about the care of your lashes.

This is actually a 3.5 star review, not really 4 stars. I like most features of this product (good color, tube formulation, non- smudge, extends lash length very nicely, and easy removal). The problem is in application. It gets gloppy!! The company needs to alter the brush so that it doesn't make your lashes glop together. Lashes should fan out as they extend. I still can't help but wonder if my $8 L'Oreal Tube Mascara is better overall. It does not make my lashes as long or thick as Lash Extend, but it does separate and fan them out and doesn't glue them together. Pros and cons to both brands.

Coats well but does not give the fullness and length advertised.

I heard about this mascara from a social media influencer, and I am impressed, because my lashes are very straight and I didn't have to use a curler. Only reason not getting a perfect score is that I wish it would wash off easier.

Excellent product. I’m older and don’t like clumped lashes. This product does not clump but is very natural looking. I use remover to get it off but soap and water would work also. Highly recommend.