Hourglass Unlocked + Caution Mascara Duo

Liked but not the best I’ve ever tried.

I've tried both of these before from Sephora and loved them, so thought I'd order from Amazon which is easier. Received both and tried the Unlocked first. Didn't want to open the other bottle (Caution) until I needed it. After a month of Unlocked, the orifice reducer dislodged so everything came out in a big blob. I shook it up and that must have reset the orifice reducer because it worked for another week or so. Now it's come out again and I can't make it go back. So, I opened up the Caution, which is pretty much dried up! Both mascaras should have lasted me at least 3 months each. Very disappointing. Now it's too late to return. Best save your money on these items from Amazon.

I saw Milabu test this. Bought the Unlocked & Caution hopeful it wouldn't smudge like my Maybelline New York Lash Sensational (waterproof) does/did. Feel like a complete idiot spending over $50 and getting the same embarrassing look. My window for return has closed- as I rarely wear make-up and foolishly didn't make sure I was satisfied with it right after receiving it.

I was excited to purchase this mascara set. Ended up extremely disappointed. Both were dry, both produce clumpy flaky lashes. Very expensive for such poor results.