Aurora Intensively Precise Eyeliner in Mushroom, Gray

I will start with saying I got this eyeliner in brown in my Ipsy bag. I LOVED it. Easy to apply, lovely color, did not run (sometimes a problem when I messed up and no time to conceal), but overall great product. My liner lasted about 4 months with almost every day use. I finally ran out and found it on Amazon which I loved because I love 2-day shipping. I ordered the brown and wanted to try the mushroom.Soooo.... I try the mushroom color, it is almost dry! Doesn't apply well and frankly, the color is not pretty at all. I'm not sure if I got a defective product and due to it being almost dry altered the color. IDK. I did return it and of course had no questions asked as it was within the return period. I will order this Aurora liner again but not in the mushroom color. I will stick with the brown. Still my favorite liner.I give the brown liner 5 stars and the mushroom liner 1 only because I was not able to use at all.

Best eye liner ever!!

This brand is my favorite eyeliner. It goes on perfectly and lasts all day long.

Horrible color - more like rust than brown. Doesn't stay put and not easy to apply.

will buy again!